Kurdistan Bloggers Union NYTimes Book Review - Kurdistan Bloggers Union

« Home | Hyphenated Ethnicity » | The Importance of Voice » | Kurdish Bloggers in the News » | Kurdish Tea? » | An alternative opinion? » | New Badge » | New Project from Delal » | Problems with Kurdish democracy: Unrest in Duhok » | Delal has been very active recently..She has been ... » | Someone explain this to me.... » 

Sunday, December 25, 2005 

NYTimes Book Review

There is an excerpt from the new Stephen Kinzer book Kurds in Turkey: The Big Change. I am not the biggest Kinzer fan, but it looks like it might be an interesting read. Here is a little bit of it:

A book fair was underway while I was in Diyarbakir. At the first stand I visited, wedged between Turkish translations of War and Peace and For Whom the Bell Tolls, I found a selection of books with titles like History of Kurdistan and Turkey's Kurdish Problem. No such books could possibly have been sold here during the 1990s, when the very word "Kurdistan" was taboo and the term "Kurdish problem" was taken to refer to an illegal form of separatism.

"Before, we were afraid to speak out," a Kurdish writer named Lutfi Baski told me at the fair. "The government was insisting that there were no Kurds, that there was no Kurdish language or culture. They arrested us and closed our organizations. Now, so much has changed, especially in the last few months. Our problems haven't been solved, not at all, but at least we can talk about them honestly. It's a huge difference."

Later that day, I walked past city hall and saw a large banner advertising a conference that was being held inside. Its subject was "The European Union Accession Process and the Kurdish Problem." When I walked into the packed hall, a local politician was delivering a passionate harangue.

"For so many years, the Turkish state called us criminals, saying that it was not possible to have dialogue with us and that we had to be crushed," he told the rapt crowd. "This is the repeated tragedy that created the Kurdish problem. The only reason Kurds were forced to begin armed struggle was the way the Turkish state has treated Kurds at every stage in the history of this country."

These would have been highly dangerous words a couple of years ago. Even now, police agents monitor and videotape conferences like this one. Their presence, however, did nothing to intimidate the speakers in Diyarbakir. "They watch us just like before, but they can't do anything to us anymore," one man told me. "This is a democracy now. We're becoming European. The state can't touch us."

Just so that I am completely understood and not mis-labeled, I want to make it clear beyond any doubt that I am an enthusiastic "balcony person" on matters related to the free and unfettered peaceful congregation, and expression of Kurdish Turks.

I found the sections on Hekarî and the question of amnesty very interesting. However, I am still skeptical about which way everything is going to go because appearances can be deceiving and there is still no consistent, official policy on Kurds, as well as the fact that there has been too much foot-dragging and wasting of time and opportunities on the part of the Turkish government.

Stephen Kinzer. . . he is always a bit overly enthusiastic and optimistic.

Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger